Car and Driver tested seven mid-size sedans priced around $20,000 to determine the best family hauler. The lineup included the Dodge Stratus, Ford Contour, Honda Accord, Mazda 626, Nissan Altima, Oldsmobile Cutlass, and Toyota Camry.
This 1998 comparison represents a critical market segment. Buyers shopping in this price band demanded reliability, practicality, and enough features to justify their investment. The Japanese manufacturers dominated this category with proven track records. Honda and Toyota delivered consistent resale value and durability. Mazda offered driving engagement that competitors couldn't match. Nissan's Altima brought a fresh approach to the segment.
American entries faced headwinds. The Dodge Stratus and Ford Contour competed on value and content, but struggled against established Japanese rivals in long-term ownership costs. The Oldsmobile Cutlass faced an uphill battle in a shrinking segment.
This comparison matters because it captured the market at a turning point. Japanese automakers had refined their sedan formulas while American manufacturers still pursued sales volume over brand loyalty. The winner likely delivered the best balance of driving dynamics, interior space, warranty coverage, and predicted reliability ratings. For families seeking transportation without compromise, this test provided the data to separate genuine quality from marketing noise.